30 Comments
User's avatar
Craig in Maine's avatar

Steve, I’d like to know which of your many writings got you in the most trouble.

Do you have an equivalent of John Derbyshire’s “Talk”?

Danfromdc's avatar

That’s a good question. Prob the New Orleans Katrina line about blacks having poor native judgment. My guess. I think that Podhoretz called him reprllent (that’s how he spelled it). To think lardass Jpod would try and call anyone repellent.

Steve has broached the JQ occasionally but not too much. Maybe something about how WASPS had noblesse oblige but our current elites (cough, cough) not so much.

noochness's avatar

Your review of the Neil Young bio 'Shakey'!

Steve Sailer's avatar

Probably the least attention anything I wrote ever got was my review of a Kurt Cobain biography, which I filed at about 3am on September 11, 2001.

noochness's avatar

I knew there was a reason I always liked UPI more than AP:

https://www.upi.com/Odd_News/2001/10/16/Book-Review-Cobain-The-Last-Rock-Legend/82891003255268/

Please consider publishing a volume of your book reviews (and of course a volume of your movie reviews too)!

delmar jackson's avatar

I think the best thing that Steve ever wrote was on immigration and how Professor George borjas of Harvard published studies showing that there is very little if any economic benefit from immigration and what benefit there is is almost always captured by those who hire immigrants and the immigrants themselves. More importantly Steve is the only person I have ever read that talked about another sociologist professor who rebutted professor borjas immigration work by claiming immigration to Miami during the 1980s showed that Miami gained a lot of economic benefit. Even though I am a Miami native I had forgotten the waterfall of cocaine in the billions of dollars that flooded into the Miami economy during the 1980s until Steve mentioned it. Immigration is about three things profit power and Punishment people refuse to talk about power and Punishment but can be persuaded when they realize there's no economic benefit from it at all to the rest of us the only stronger argument for Less immigration is how our grandchildren will become a hated minority in a land of our fathers I think Steve has done more to sway the immigration argument than anyone I know of.

Steve Sailer's avatar

David Card won the Nobel in part for his Miami Mariel study.

The Anti-Gnostic's avatar

You should do greatest hits by decade or maybe greatest hits in five year increments. Or you could conclude that's a wasteful exercise since humans just make the same mistakes, at least twice a generation, and everyone's still proving you right. That's why I got bored with long-form blogging. Congratulations on still bringing a fresh perspective and clever turn of phrase!

Ralph L's avatar

For a few seconds, I thought I was reading Jimmy Carter, then I remembered he didn't wish Israel well. Why haven't they given the West Bank back to Jordan? King doesn't want it?

Erik's avatar

Jordan had a bad time the last time they let in a bunch of "palestinians"

Ralph L's avatar

Makes you wonder if they lost the Six Day War on purpose.

Erik's avatar

ha- I don't think anyone loses a war on purpose. I did recently learn something--the six day war was triggered in part, by France cutting off Israel's weapon supply (even refusing to deliver some planes they had already paid for--didn'rt return the money either).

John's avatar

Since I often quote Big Steve in my Ricochet posts, I thought I might be able to give objective data: what have I implicitly asserted to be the man’s greatest hits? I had thought I’d cited several times his January 1, 2014 article titled The Shadowy Imam of the Poconos, but no, I only did that once. At whatever frequency, though, it’s still a great one.

Though not broached in the OP, I’d like to mention some non-Taki’s content that I have admiringly recycled. Again, to judge from my personal archive, I never hammered with any single iSteve blog post. The man stays fresh and so do I! Indeed, I seek freshness so diligently, I even reach for comments within a blog post. The one I remember best – although I can’t find it now – was from someone who apparently was a civil engineer, ferociously deriding all the other commenters who weren’t as they vainly chipped in on why that pedestrian bridge in Florida collapsed a few years ago. “You all sound like liberals talking about guns,” he said, and I believe he was right.

Though probably not a field of inquiry that Steve has sought to make a name in, I see I have fairly often reached for his stuff on subjects southeast-European. There was a post about Operation Storm, and one about the Chinese Embassy in Belgrade, and also at least one about the Russo-Georgian war of 2008. Probably no one’s idea of greatest hits, but they did help me make this or that point on another website.

PE Bird's avatar

A book of all your Taki articles would be a fantastic read. Of course one could just click on them but it would be nice to have a physical copy.

Perhaps an article combining the themes of "The Rise and Fall of Statistics" with "The Self-Righteous Hive Mind" would provide some insights into the explosion of useless sports "metrics". Could also also insert something about gambling.

Steve Sailer's avatar

Thanks. My first couple of years weren't that good. Then I hit my stride around 2011 or 2012 and then the Great Awokening got going to provide a huge amount of material.

Erik's avatar

Your Israel Palestine column actually aged poorly. I too used to think along those lines--give em a state and then when you get attacked by that state the world will understand if you have to kick its ass.

WRT your dictator preserving his shiny toys hypothesis--that works with sane dictators. In Gaza they actually elected the terrorists dictator (they didn't necessarily think that it would be the final election but whatayagonnado?) And did the Hamas government like their shiny toys enough to stop pestering the local super power? No. They attacked and when Israel kicked their ass, they refused to surrender, preferring the public relations coup of having their beautiful "open air prison cum refugee camp" flattened.

Turns out "palestinians" are a special kind of crazy.

Steve Sailer's avatar

Yeah, I had a hot streak on foreign policy for awhile, but I've been colder lately, so I write even less about it.

Erik's avatar

As Yogi Bear once said, it's difficult to make predictions, especially about foreign affairs, especially while Trump is president.

Ralph L's avatar

Reading about Shakespeare and royal breeding makes me wonder why royal families didn't fear that marrying the child of a madman or idiot might be problematic.

Steve Sailer's avatar

My vague impression is that the English in Shakespeare's time wanted to do scientific breeding for horses and to a lesser extent for cows and pigs and wheat, but not quite enough to do the hard work of thorough record keeping and statistical analysis of what worked and what didn't work. So they relied on rules of thumb and general impressions of tricks of the trade, which kind of sort of worked. Finally, around 1760 a handful of farmers got down to work and started making steady progress.

But statistical reasoning lagged ridiculously far behind: Galton unveiled the correlation coefficient in 1888, two centuries after Newton had invented calculus to figure out his law of gravity.

Gabe's avatar

Now I know why I don’t like soccer and European soccer leagues never appealed to me. I guess I never felt the need to one-up the chuds on how sophisticated I am. It also explains why I’m a big Cal football fan despite Berkeley being a kinda ugly and gritty town filled with homeless, and extreme liberal freaks. From a concentric POV that makes sense, my family has been going to games for generations and it’s the closest team to me.

AnotherDad's avatar

Something on "Affordable Family Formation".

Trump's made some good progress on the illegal half of the immivasion. But here we are off slapping around drug-running dictators and threatening liberation of ice covered "Greenland", while the 2nd pillar of the destruction of the West--the fertility collapse--gets nary a word.

The pre-coup old Waspy American elite of a century back was clearly on the right track with their eugenic concerns. The civilized races are now in outright demographic collapse while the most useless races continue to breed like rabbits.

m droy's avatar

"Israel, the regional military superpower, can intimidate these into suppressing their native terrorists."

What native terrorists are these. Look at Syria where not a single of the many named terrorist groups have ever threatened israel*. Are any of them natives? of course not. Some 10,000 of them are Ujghurs, not just not native to Syria, not native to ME, but long the tools of MI6 and CIA to create rebellion in China. 25 years or rapid growth and good times for the Ujghurs has meant they job is pointless over there so they were miraculously passed through to Turkey where the families lived while the terrorists killed Syrians in the expecation they would gain land and homes in Syria. Turned out right for them in the end.

* well no terrorist leader has bad mouthed Israel to date. I gather the crowds of modern Joolani thugs now often shout threats of what they will do to

"Admittedly, though, I’m bored with Israel vs. Palestine."

But why on earth doesn't the Blindness of so much of US to a blatant genocide interest you.

Surely it is the biggest mass delusion around - far more than BLM, defund the Police or the denial of IQ and race.

You are ducking out on the biggest story around. Why?

Chip Witch's avatar

I decided to see if I’d bookmarked any of your Taki columns; oddly, there’s only one. It’s this 2021 piece on “Distaff Writers”.

https://www.takimag.com/article/distaff-writers/

I just reread it and I think it holds up. I think at the time I was struck by the point that Prohibition made it so nobody wanted to listen to women for a few decades.

Philip Neal's avatar

To those who have vaguely heard of him, Steve Sailer is that MAGA blogger who writes about race, yet only one of the selected columns is about race in America, and many recurring themes were omitted. Golf courses, modern architecture and generous pieces about people (the Baltimore bridge, Trump's ear) who did their jobs well.

I mean it as a compliment to them both when I say that for range, originality and output he is, in his very different way, the equal of Martin Gardner and should have had the same renown.

Richard North's avatar

The Righteous Mind is one of my favourite books so thankyou for the great insight about the essential difference between conservatives and liberals. It's a lot simpler than Haidt's analysis and it works.

James K O'Sullivan's avatar

Re: Raising the Bard

"Who needs reason when you have Lived Experience?"

One thing - perhaps the only thing - that annoys me about you is your dismissive attitude towards the Shakespeare Authorship Question. If the Bard had copious Lived Experience, when did he experience it?

The "Lost Years" number only seven. What written records we have of the next twenty years of the lived experience of "English language’s best-known pre-Enlightenment writer," according to the conventional wisdom, consist mostly of those those that might be expected of an ambitious exurban man of that period: moneylending, arbitrage of agricultural commodities and such, as well as dodging charges of grain hoarding during a famine and tax evasion.

Sure, he spend some time in London, involved in the nascent industry of theatre production. But the only mark left of him in town was the disembodied name "William Shakespeare" attached to some of the plays (and poems! he was poet, too). And during that time, it was a two-day ride between London, where the theatres were, and Stratford, where, during that same time, he engaged in those well-documented bucolic pursuits.