Discussion about this post

User's avatar
TonyZa's avatar

You've shown plenty of talent, courage and honesty so it's normal that those who sold themselves in the service of lies hate you.

Expand full comment
Paulus's avatar

There is a YouTube lecture on Epistemology by Robert Jenson, a left-wing journalism professor. He discusses the question, “On what do we base our understanding of what is true?”Jenson asserts that we do so in three ways: correspondence, coherence, consensus.

Correspondence: something is true when it corresponds to reality. The scientific method is intended to establish knowledge of this sort.

Coherence: What is reality may be beyond our comprehension, so we test our truth claims by whether they fit with other things we believe to be true. We don’t believe different truth claims separately, we believe them as part of a worldview.

Consensus: Something is “true” when we achieve a consensus about it. It doesn’t have to meet the standard of correspondence or coherence as long as it works best for us as a group, that the consensus helps us to solve problems. When NPR CEO Katherine Maher famously stated, “Our reverence for the truth might be a distraction that is getting in the way of finding common ground and getting things done,” she was promoting this last version of truth. It’s what Plato called the Noble Lie, a myth or doctrine promoted to maintain social order, “for the greater good.”

The fundamental principle of liberalism is nondiscrimination. Survival of the liberal social order requires the noble lie that races and sexes are equal in ability. Any difference in outcomes must be ascribed to social inequality. As Ibram X Kendi states, “Either something is wrong with black people or something is wrong with society,” and you are forbidden to believe the former. For Steve Sailer to suggest that 50% of discrepancies might be due to innate differences is unacceptable. We must ignore scientific facts and our lived experience to support the noble lie.

Expand full comment
94 more comments...

No posts