Here’s an interesting 2022 report by University College London criminologist Matt Ashby et al: “Benchmarking Crime in London Against Other Global Cities.”
Ashby tries to do an apples to apples comparison of the crime rates in London to those of other major First World cities such as as New York, Chicago, Los Angeles, Paris, Berlin, Milan, Tokyo, and Singapore.
One obvious conundrum is defining who exactly is in a city.
For example, the Chicago Metropolitan Statistical Area has a population of 9.4 million, including Gary, IN. The Chicago MSA used to also include Kenosha, WI, but that was recently excluded.
A moderate definition of Chicago would include all 5.3 million people of Cook County, IL, including famous suburbs like Evanston and Oak Park. Pope Leo grew up just over the Chicago boundary in the suburb of Dolton. But, Ashby reports:
The boundary of the City of Chicago covers a relatively small proportion of the urban area. However, the city is surrounded by many small cities that do not publish consistent crime data, so the only option is to use data for the City of Chicago only.
Frank Lloyd Wright’s most famous suburban house, the Robie House, is in Hyde Park, which is legally within the municipality of Chicago boundaries. But the largest concentration of Wright Prairie Style suburban houses are a few hundred feet outside of Chicago in Oak Park.
Here’s Wright’s deranged-looking Tudor-Samurai-Mayan Moore House that he built next door to my father’s boyhood home after Wright’s original Tudor cottage burned down on Christmas Day 1922:
My wife grew up a few blocks away, but in the city of Chicago.
Anyway, I’m getting off topic …
So, only the 2.7 million people living in the legal city of Chicago are counted in Ashby’s study, which tends to drive up Chicago crime rates by excluding many of its genteel leafy suburbs.
But Ashby makes his most reasonable choices as to which boundaries to use.
Not surprisingly, American homicide rates are much, much worse than those of Europe or the Orient.
America has a lot of guns and a lot of blacks, which tends to be a shooty combination.
What’s perhaps more interesting is that …
Paywall here.





