Steve Sailer

Steve Sailer

What Is the Root Cause of Crime?

A PBS documentary wonders why America has so many guys in prison: Racism? Inequality?

Steve Sailer's avatar
Steve Sailer
Nov 20, 2026
∙ Paid

America recently went through a colossal experiment in which we implemented The Experts’ views on what is wrong with Crime and Punishment: namely, too much Punishment and too much Policing.

Not surprisingly, it was a huge disaster, especially for black lives. Tens of thousands of incremental black lives were terminated by homicides and car crashes in 2015-2024 compared to the 2010-2014 before BLM became an elite obsession.

But, somehow I don’t think the current eight hour documentary on PBS brought to you by executive producer Ken Burns will show one of my countless graphs.

This week on PBS, there’s a new 8 hour documentary series called “Crime and Punishment in America.” Ken Burns puts his name on it as an executive producer, but the director is Lynn Novick. As far as I can tell from interviews with her, it’s straight out of the New Jim Crow conventional wisdom of the recent (but now memoryholed) Black Lives Matter mania about how racism was the root cause of mass incarceration and instead we should be working on the root causes of crimes like inequity.

From PBS:

Nearly two million people are behind bars in the US. How did we get here?

November 16, 202612:34 PM ET

Heard on Fresh Air

By Dave Davies

Transcript

Lynn Novick’s new, four-part PBS documentary series, Crime and Punishment in America, goes inside the U.S. prison system and explores how

DAVE DAVIES, HOST:

This is FRESH AIR. I’m Dave Davies. … That story is among the revelations in a remarkable documentary series about crime and punishment in America coming to PBS this week, directed by our guest today, Lynn Novick.

The four-part series takes us from a day when prisons were largely unknown to the America of today, where nearly 2 million people are behind bars, a rate far higher than other industrialized countries. …

Lynn Novick is an award-winning documentary filmmaker who’s collaborated with Ken Burns on many of his acclaimed series. Her most recent series, “College Behind Bars,” was about men and women earning college degrees while incarcerated. Her series “Crime And Punishment In America” will air over four consecutive nights on PBS beginning tonight. …

DAVIES: You know, one theme that runs throughout this documentary series from the earliest times of the republic to today is racism and its connection to law enforcement. It was particularly tough, of course, in the South, where lynchings were, for many, many decades, a method of control. And there’s one case that’s described in some detail here of a man named Henry Smith in Paris, Texas. You want to tell us who he was and what he was accused of?

NOVICK: Henry Smith was a teenager in the town of Paris, Texas, and he was accused of killing and possibly molesting a little girl - a 4-year-old girl. And he was Black, and the little girl was white. And the little girl’s father was a police officer in the town. And he - when he found out he was accused, he ran away.

From Wikipedia:

Henry Smith was a handyman in Paris, Texas. One day in early 1893, he was seen acting drunk and disorderly, and Deputy Henry Vance was sent to arrest Smith. Smith resisted, and Vance “was forced to use his club” to subdue him.[5] On Thursday, January 26, 1893, Henry Vance’s three-year-old daughter disappeared from the front of the boarding house where her family lived. Witnesses said that they saw Smith “picked up little Myrtle Vance ... and ... carry her through the central portion of the city. En route through the city, several people asked him what he was doing with the child.” One of the witnesses Smith spoke to was the mayor of Paris. Smith claimed that he was taking her to her mother or the doctor. Smith returned home on Friday morning. His wife asked him about “that white child”. Smith replied: “I ain’t seen no white child and don’t have nothing to do with white folks.” Smith left and was not seen again until he was captured in Arkansas.

Americans were so racist that they really didn’t like it when a criminal gets his revenge on a cop by kidnapping, murdering, and probably raping the policeman’s toddler daughter.

Back to PBS:

And so there was a man hunt. And during the time of this man hunt for him, it really became a frenzy. So by the time he was captured and brought back to the town, I think the whole nation was watching. And there were thousands of people that came there from all over the state of Texas, especially chartered trains were brought in to watch him be put to death in the most horrific, barbaric way you can imagine.

DAVIES: Now, was Henry Smith mentally handicapped in some way?

NOVICK: He was known in the town to be weak minded or feeble minded. That could be that he had an intellectual disability or a mental illness or both. And he was known for erratic behavior. But there was no due process here, so he was killed in front of thousands of people and tortured without ever having a chance to talk to a lawyer, have a trial, have representation or have any kind of legal system functioning to see whether anything that he was accused of actually happened.

Of course, Smith was …

Paywall here.

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Steve Sailer.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Steve Sailer · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.